Lease vs Buy a Car: The Complete 2026 Comparison Guide
Quick Answer
The bottom line: Buying costs less over 5+ years if you keep the car. Leasing offers lower monthly payments and a new car every 3 years, but you never build equity. Buy if: you drive 15,000+ miles/year, keep cars 5+ years, or want to customize. Lease if: you want lower payments, always drive new, and stay under 12,000-15,000 miles/year.
Key Stat: Buying saves approximately $4,000-8,000 over 6 years compared to leasing twice.
Calculate Your Car PaymentThe Lease vs Buy Basics
Before diving into numbers, let's clarify what each option actually means:
What Is a Car Lease?
A lease is essentially a long-term rental. You pay for the vehicle's depreciation during the time you use it (typically 2-3 years), plus interest and fees. At the end, you return the car—you never owned it.
What Does Buying Mean?
Buying means you're purchasing the vehicle outright—either with cash or a loan. With a loan, you make payments until it's paid off, then you own the car free and clear. You can keep it, sell it, or trade it in whenever you want.
The fundamental difference: Leasing pays for using a car. Buying pays for owning a car. That ownership has value at the end—leasing doesn't.
Total Cost Comparison: 6-Year Analysis
Monthly payments tell only part of the story. Here's what leasing vs buying really costs over 6 years using a $35,000 vehicle:
| Cost Factor | Lease (2x 3-yr) | Buy (6 years) |
|---|---|---|
| Down payment/due at signing | $2,000 × 2 = $4,000 | $5,000 |
| Monthly payments | $450 × 72 mo = $32,400 | $575 × 60 mo = $34,500 |
| Maintenance | ~$1,200 (mostly covered) | ~$4,500 |
| Insurance | ~$8,100 (full coverage req.) | ~$7,200 |
| Disposition/fees | ~$700 | $0 |
| Total 6-Year Cost | $46,400 | $51,200 |
| Value at end | $0 | ~$12,000 |
| Net 6-Year Cost | $46,400 | $39,200 |
The verdict: Buying saves ~$7,200 over 6 years in this example. The longer you keep a purchased car, the more you save—years 7+ are nearly "free" (just maintenance and insurance).
Monthly Payment Comparison
Lease payments are typically 20-40% lower than loan payments for the same car. Here's why:
| Factor | Lease (36 mo) | Buy (60 mo loan) |
|---|---|---|
| What you're paying for | 3 years of depreciation | Full vehicle price |
| Typical monthly payment | $420-$480 | $550-$620 |
| Down payment typical | $0-$2,000 | $3,500-$7,000 (10-20%) |
| What you own at end | Nothing | The car (~$12,000 value) |
Why are lease payments lower? You're only paying for depreciation during your lease term (typically 40-50% of the car's value), not the whole vehicle. It's cheaper per month but you're building zero equity.
The hidden cost of lower payments: Lower monthly payments can tempt people to lease more expensive cars than they'd buy. A $450/month lease on a $45,000 car costs the same as buying a $35,000 car—but the lease costs more long-term and you own nothing.
Understanding Lease Costs
Leases have several costs beyond the monthly payment that can surprise you:
Money Factor
This is the lease equivalent of an interest rate. To convert money factor to APR, multiply by 2,400. A money factor of 0.00285 equals about 6.84% APR.
Residual Value
The predicted value of the car at lease end. Higher residual = lower payments (you're paying for less depreciation). Manufacturers sometimes inflate residuals to offer attractive lease deals.
Common Lease Fees
| Fee Type | Typical Amount | When Paid |
|---|---|---|
| Acquisition fee | $595-$995 | Lease start |
| Disposition fee | $350-$500 | Lease end (if returning) |
| Excess mileage | $0.15-$0.30/mile | Lease end |
| Excess wear & tear | $500-$2,000+ | Lease end |
| Early termination | Remaining payments + fees | If you exit early |
Mileage Penalties: A Real Example
Standard lease limits are 10,000-12,000 miles/year. Here's what happens if you drive 15,000 miles/year over a 3-year lease:
- Annual excess: 3,000 miles × 3 years = 9,000 miles over
- At $0.25/mile: $2,250 due at lease end
High mileage? If you drive 15,000+ miles/year, buying almost always wins. The mileage penalties alone can eliminate any savings from lower lease payments.
Understanding Buying Costs
Buying has its own set of costs to consider:
Interest Over Time
On a $30,000 loan at 6.8% for 60 months, you'll pay about $5,400 in interest. Shorter terms (48 months) save interest but increase monthly payments.
Maintenance Reality
| Year | Typical Annual Cost | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Years 1-3 | $200-$400 | Basic maintenance, warranty covers most |
| Years 4-5 | $500-$800 | Tires, brakes, larger services |
| Years 6-8 | $800-$1,200 | Potential bigger repairs |
| Years 9+ | $1,000-$2,000 | Age-related repairs increase |
Depreciation: The Silver Lining
Yes, cars depreciate—but you still own something at the end. A well-maintained 6-year-old car worth $12,000 is real value you can use as a trade-in, sell privately, or continue driving "for free" (no payments).
The "free car" years: Once your loan is paid off (typically month 60), every additional month you drive is essentially free—just maintenance, insurance, and fuel. Years 6-10 are when buying really pays off.
Decision Framework: Which Is Right for You?
Lease If You...
- Drive under 12,000-15,000 miles/year—stay within limits to avoid penalties
- Want predictable costs—maintenance covered under warranty, no surprise repairs
- Value newest safety tech—latest driver assistance features every 3 years
- Change cars every 2-3 years anyway—leasing formalizes this habit
- Have stable income and budget—committed to payments for 3 years
- Take good care of vehicles—avoid wear and tear charges
Buy If You...
- Drive 15,000+ miles/year—avoid mileage penalties
- Keep cars 5+ years—maximize the "free car" years
- Want to customize—tint, wheels, aftermarket parts (prohibited on leases)
- Have variable income—flexibility to pause payment focus if needed
- Want to build equity—own something at the end
- Don't mind maintenance—willing to handle repairs after warranty
The simplest rule: If you'll keep a car less than 4 years, leasing may work. If you'll keep it 5+ years, buying almost always wins financially.
Lease Negotiation Strategies
Many people don't realize you can negotiate a lease. Here's what's on the table:
Negotiable Items
- Capitalized cost (the vehicle price)—most important! Negotiate like you're buying
- Money factor—ask for rate sheet; compare to competitors
- Acquisition fee—sometimes negotiable, sometimes not
- Mileage allowance—buy extra miles upfront (cheaper than penalties)
The Cap Cost Trick
Every $1,000 reduction in capitalized cost lowers your monthly payment by about $28 on a 36-month lease. Negotiate the price FIRST, as if you're buying, then discuss lease terms.
Best Time to Lease
- End of month/quarter/year—dealers need to hit targets
- When new model arrives—outgoing model gets incentives
- Holiday sales events—manufacturer incentives
Lease-End Options Explained
When your lease ends, you have three choices:
Option 1: Return the Car
Simply turn it in, pay any excess mileage or wear charges, and walk away. You'll owe the disposition fee ($350-$500) unless you lease another vehicle from the same brand.
Option 2: Lease a New Vehicle
Most common choice. Start a new lease with a new car. Disposition fee is usually waived. This keeps you in the lease cycle—lower payments but perpetual car payments.
Option 3: Buy Out Your Lease
Purchase the car for the residual value stated in your contract. This can be a great deal OR a bad deal depending on the car's actual market value.
When Buyouts Make Sense
- Residual value is below market value (you're getting a deal)
- You've exceeded mileage limits (buying avoids the penalty)
- You love the car and it's in great condition
- The car has been reliable and you know its history
Buyout Calculation Example
Your lease states residual value of $18,000. Check KBB/Edmunds—if similar cars sell for $21,000, buying at $18,000 is a good deal. If they sell for $16,000, return the car and buy elsewhere.
Special Situations
Business Use
For business vehicles, leasing may offer tax advantages. Lease payments can be deducted as a business expense (subject to luxury vehicle limits). However, if you use the standard mileage deduction for taxes, buying might be simpler. Consult a tax professional—the "best" choice depends on your specific situation.
High Mileage Drivers
If you drive 18,000+ miles annually, buying almost always wins. On a 3-year lease, you'd face 18,000+ excess miles at $0.20-0.30/mile = $3,600-$5,400 in penalties. That cost elimination alone tips the math toward buying.
New vs Used in the Equation
While leases are typically for new cars, buying opens up the used market. A 2-3 year old certified pre-owned (CPO) vehicle can offer:
- 30-40% lower price than new
- Remaining factory warranty plus CPO warranty
- Lower insurance costs
- Someone else absorbed the steepest depreciation
CPO tip: Buying a 2-3 year old CPO vehicle is often the best financial move—you avoid the new car premium while still getting warranty protection and a relatively new car.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is leasing a car a waste of money?
Leasing isn't inherently a waste—it depends on your situation. If you drive under 12,000 miles/year, want lower payments, and prefer a new car every 3 years, leasing can make sense. However, if you keep cars long-term, leasing costs more because you never build equity. After 6 years of leasing, you'll have nothing to show for your payments.
Can I negotiate a car lease?
Yes! Many people don't realize lease terms are negotiable. You can negotiate the vehicle price (capitalized cost), money factor (interest rate equivalent), and acquisition fee. The most important item to negotiate is the capitalized cost—every $1,000 reduction lowers your monthly payment by about $28 on a 36-month lease.
What happens if I exceed mileage on a lease?
You'll pay an excess mileage charge, typically $0.15 to $0.30 per mile over your limit. On a 36-month lease with a 12,000-mile annual limit, driving 15,000 miles/year would cost you an extra $1,350 to $2,700 at lease end. If you know you'll exceed the limit, either buy pre-paid miles upfront (cheaper) or consider buying instead.
Should I buy my leased car at the end?
It depends on the buyout price versus market value. Check what similar vehicles sell for on sites like KBB or Edmunds. If the buyout price is lower than market value, buying makes sense—especially if you've kept the car in great condition. If the buyout is higher than market value, return the car and shop elsewhere.
Is leasing better for business use?
Leasing can offer tax advantages for business use since lease payments may be fully deductible as a business expense (subject to luxury vehicle limits). However, if you use the standard mileage deduction, buying might be simpler. Consult a tax professional—the best choice depends on your business structure, usage percentage, and overall tax situation.
Your Lease vs Buy Action Plan
Step 1: Calculate Your Annual Mileage
Check your odometer and estimate yearly driving. Under 12,000 = lease possible. Over 15,000 = strongly consider buying.
Step 2: Decide How Long You Keep Cars
Be honest about your history. If you've never kept a car more than 4 years, leasing aligns with your behavior. If you drive cars "until they die," buying wins big.
Step 3: Compare Total Costs for Your Situation
Don't just compare monthly payments. Calculate the full cost over 5-6 years including maintenance, insurance, and end value.
Step 4: Get Quotes for Both Options
For the same vehicle, get both lease and purchase quotes. Compare apples to apples with the same down payment and term considerations.
Ready to Calculate Your Monthly Payment?
Use our auto loan calculator to see exactly what your monthly car payment would be if you buy, including how extra payments can help you pay off faster.
Calculate Your Car Payment